Featured post


A conversation is recounted in the book # Shantaram  in which the character, Khaderbhai, says: “There is no such thing as believing in #G...

Get all my postings delivered to you by email. I will never share your details with anyone.

Wednesday, 20 November 2013


I am not normally given to ranting, but perhaps readers will indulge me on this occasion.

I felt disturbed and nauseated the other evening when I saw a photograph on my wife's Facebook page of a foraging elephant which had been assassinated by a hunter.  Posing next to the fallen elephant was a picture of the hunter,a woman and three children whom I took to be his family.  All were grinning from ear to ear and looking quite pleased with themselves.  Then along comes the sickening image of Melissa Bachman crouched and beaming superciliously next to an African lion she has murdered. 

I find every cell in my body filled with revulsion and judgement.  The comments of others on the elephant photograph echoed my dismay and condemnation.  A whole Facebook page has been created and devoted to putting a stop to the likes of Melissa Bachman.  

There is a part of me that would happily populate this post with my words of abuse, condemnation and judgment, but my sense is that that simply has the effect of stirring up other people’s outrage without canvassing the real issues.  Let me see if I can rather distill out some of the issues.

My initial outrage is about someone – presumably a foreigner with no sense of African heritage – coming to my continent and paying money to slay the mightiest of God’s creatures.  My fury is founded in a sense of ownership that I and so many Africans have in our wildlife and our bush heritage.  It doesn't matter that I don’t physically own the elephant or the lion:  I believe that it is my right, and the right of my children and their children to see, connect with and honour what remains of our planet in its natural state.  Unless you have spent time in Africa, you cannot begin to understand the depth of feeling and reverence which Africans have toward their wildlife.  Not all Africans, granted, but for the most part, it is difficult for the bush not to get right into your bones.

No one asked me whether it was OK for foreigners (or indeed anyone) to come and destroy some of my heritage.  No one asked for permission to destroy the rights of yet to be born grandchildren to connect with the earth.  Of course, elephants, rhinos and lions evoke more emotion and attract more attention than 'lesser' animals, but the principle remains the same:  this is our African heritage.  If Americans, Europeans, Japanese and whoever else don’t care about the planet, let them mess up their own piece of the planet, but it is not OK to mess up mine.

And as for the hunter and his family?  And Melissa Bachman?  Well, I don’t know what those supercilious smiles are all about - pride? courage? self-importance? achievement?  What I do know, however, is that it is the easiest thing in the world to get close to an elephant.  The target is the biggest one in the world.  Provided you have the right weapon, you will bring the beast down.  Canned lion hunting is even more cowardly.  With those facts, where is the sport, where is the achievement and for what possible reason can you feel proud about the destruction of such majestic creatures?  

Although I promised at the beginning of this post not to start bandying labels around, I am left with no other judgement but that these are acts of pure self-indulgence which amount to nothing more than the hunter's way of proving his or her own self-worth.

If the destruction of life is the hunter’s way of proving self-worth to the world, it seems to me that he or she has many lifetimes to go.

1 comment:

  1. This is about her, and life. What about you Andrew? It sounds as you are deeply wounded and outraged and that there is some exploring underneath it all that might be helpful to get to forgiveness, while not condoning her actions.
    At the moment I am struggling with something similar, but it has to do with a young man who is being criminally charged, and who learnt well from his leaders. He quotes indiscriminately from Nelson Mandela when he said at the Rivonia trials "It should not be me on trial, it should be the government" taking it totally out of context of when it was said, to use it now! He is also using a tactic that other leaders have used - create enough discent and confusion amongst the masses to derail a legal process, with the hope that he will get away with his criminal activities.
    What could we, as society do about it, if we were in our higher self and on purpose? Would the media stop filming, quoting and reporting his every word, expression and silence his voice. Would it take away the platform on which he is building up to the next elections? What is it within ourselves when we know what we can do, but don't. When we allow our voices to be silenced, and play small when South Africa is facing such huge issues? I don't know the answers. I just know that, daily I look "head, heart and guts leaders, complete leaders, who have not only the intellectual capacity, but the compassion and the courage to take the reins and lead us back onto the path that we chose before 24 April 1994. When are these leaders going to emerge and get a voice?


Share your thoughts and insights